Does switching SEO companies hurt rankings?
Google does not know or care who your SEO company is. It looks at your website, your Business Profile, and what the rest of the web says about you. So the act of switching does not cost you anything on its own.
What costs you is what can go missing in the switch. The usual losses look like this:
- The old company owned the domain or the hosting, and the site goes down or gets held while you sort it out.
- The site was built on a platform the old company controls, and you cannot take the pages with you.
- Call tracking numbers that were printed on your listings get shut off, and the phone stops ringing from those listings.
- Links the old company placed on sites it controls get removed.
- Analytics and Search Console were set up under their accounts, so you lose your history.
- The new company rewrites or moves pages too fast, before it understands what was working.
Every one of those is avoidable if you do the work in the right order. The rule is simple: secure access first, give notice second, change things third.
If you are switching because you are not sure the current work is helping, read how to tell if your SEO is working first. Sometimes the problem is the reporting, not the work.
Which accounts do you need to own before you give notice?
"Own" means your name and your email address are on the account as owner or administrator. Not a login someone shared with you. Not "they said we can have it." Check each one yourself.
- Domain registrar. Log in to the company where your domain is registered and confirm you are the registrant. If the old company registered it in their name, ask for it to be moved into yours now. Under ICANN's transfer policy, some changes can trigger a 60-day lock on moving the domain to a new registrar, so start early.
- Website hosting. Know where the site lives and who pays for it. If they host it, ask for a full copy of the site and the database.
- Website admin. If the site runs on WordPress or another editor, make sure you have your own administrator login.
- Google Business Profile. You should be the primary owner. An agency can be a manager. Google explains the difference in its owners and managers help article.
- Google Search Console. Add yourself as an owner of the property. The history there is your history.
- Google Analytics. Make sure you have administrator access on the account and property, not just on a view.
- Google Tag Manager, if they use it. Ask for administrator access to the container.
- Ad accounts. Google Ads, Local Services Ads, Microsoft Ads and Meta. The ad account itself should belong to you, even if they manage it from their side.
- Call tracking. Find out who owns the numbers and whether they can be moved to your own account.
- Review and listing sites. Yelp, Bing Places, Apple Business Connect, Facebook and any industry directories. Our post on Bing Places and Apple Business Connect covers two that often get missed.
If something is in the old company's name, ask politely for it to be transferred before you mention you are leaving. Most good companies hand things over without a fuss. Our post on who owns your website explains the ownership models you might run into.
What should you back up?
Even with full access, take copies. People leave companies, accounts get closed, and memories fade.
- A full site backup, files and database, stored somewhere you control.
- A list of every URL on the site. You can export it from Search Console's Pages report or from the site's sitemap file.
- Search Console exports. Download the Performance report for the last 16 months, by query and by page. That is your before picture.
- Analytics exports. Monthly organic traffic and key events (calls and forms) for at least the last year.
- Business Profile performance. Screenshots or exports of views, calls and the search terms list.
- Every report the old company sent. The new company will want to see what was done.
- A list of links and citations they built or paid for, if they will share it.
- Ad account history, including keyword lists and negative keywords.
How do you give notice cleanly?
Read your contract before you say anything. Look for the notice period, any cancellation fee, what happens to work in progress and who owns the content. If you are still shopping, our SEO contract checklist covers the clauses worth reading before you sign the next one.
Then send notice in writing. Keep it short and professional:
- The date service ends, matching the contract's notice period.
- A list of the accounts and files you need transferred, with a date for each.
- A request that nothing on the site be removed, redirected or changed after the notice date.
- A request to keep call tracking numbers active until you can replace them on every listing.
- A thank-you. Burning the bridge helps nobody, and you may need a favor later.
Back when I was running sales for plumbing and remodeling companies, we switched vendors more than once. The handoffs that went well were the ones where we asked for everything in one clear email, with dates, before anyone got emotional about it.
What should the new company do first?
A good new SEO company should look before it touches. In the first weeks you should expect:
- An audit of the site, the Business Profile and the tracking, with findings written down.
- A check that calls and forms work and are being counted.
- A review of which pages bring in traffic and leads today, so those pages are protected.
- A plan in writing for what changes, in what order, and why.
- Redirects for any URL that moves, so old links and bookmarks still work.
Be wary of anyone who wants to rebuild the whole site in week one, or promises specific rankings by a date. Google's own guide to hiring an SEO warns that no one can guarantee a number one ranking. Our post on the first 30 days with an SEO company covers what a good month one looks like in more detail.
If the site itself needs replacing, that is a bigger project with its own risks. Our guide to rebuilding versus fixing a website helps you decide.
What should you watch in the first 60 days?
Set a weekly 10-minute check for two months.
- Search Console, Pages report. Are your important pages still indexed? A sudden drop in indexed pages is the first sign something broke.
- Search Console, Performance. Compare impressions and clicks to the same weeks last year, not just last week. Small weekly swings are normal.
- Calls and forms. Count real leads, not just clicks. If leads drop and traffic does not, check the phone numbers and forms first.
- Business Profile. Confirm the number, hours and categories did not change in the handoff.
- Site uptime. If the domain or hosting moved, check the site loads, with the padlock, on a phone and a laptop.
Rankings can wobble after any change, and some movement in the first weeks is normal. What you are looking for is a clear, lasting drop tied to something you can name: a page that disappeared, a redirect that was missed, or a phone number that stopped ringing.
The one-page handoff checklist
Print this, or copy it into a note.
- Confirm you own the domain, hosting and website admin.
- Confirm you are primary owner of the Business Profile.
- Add yourself as owner of Search Console and admin of Analytics and Tag Manager.
- Confirm ad accounts and call tracking are in your name or can be moved.
- Back up the site, the URL list and 16 months of Search Console data.
- Save every report and link list from the old company.
- Read the contract's notice and ownership clauses.
- Send written notice with a list of transfers and dates.
- Let the new company audit before it changes anything.
- Watch indexing, leads and the profile weekly for 60 days.
If you are still choosing who to switch to, our page on how to compare Denver SEO companies covers the questions that separate them. Our Denver team has handled plenty of these handoffs, and we are happy to walk yours with you.
Switching and want a second set of eyes?
Our free audit checks your accounts, tracking and site before anything moves, so you know what to protect.
Get a free audit → Call 1-800-481-8638Questions readers ask
Will switching SEO companies hurt my rankings?
Switching by itself does not. Rankings usually drop only when something is lost in the handoff, such as the domain, hosting, pages, links, tracking or phone numbers, or when the new company changes too much too fast. No one can promise zero movement, but a clean handoff removes the avoidable risks.
What accounts should I own before leaving my SEO company?
Your domain registrar, website hosting and admin, Google Business Profile as primary owner, Google Search Console as owner, Google Analytics and Tag Manager as administrator, your ad accounts, and your call tracking numbers if possible.
Should I tell my SEO company I am leaving before getting access?
It is safer to secure access first. Ask for ownership of anything in their name as a normal request, confirm it is done, and then give written notice according to your contract.
What happens to call tracking numbers when I switch?
If the old company owns them, they may be turned off when service ends, and any listing showing those numbers stops ringing. Ask to move the numbers into your own account, or replace them on every listing before service ends.
How soon should the new SEO company start making changes?
After an audit and a written plan. Fixing broken tracking, forms or phone numbers can happen right away. Bigger changes, like rewriting or moving pages, should wait until the new company knows which pages bring in leads today.
Can I keep the content and links the old company created?
Content on your site usually stays with the site, but check your contract for who owns it. Links on other websites may stay or be removed depending on who controls those sites, which is why it helps to ask for a list before you leave.

