Guaranteed SEO is a red flag. Here is what to ask instead.

What Google says about guarantees

Google publishes a page for business owners called “Do you need an SEO?”. It is short, plain, and worth reading before you sign anything. Three points in it matter here.

• No one can guarantee a #1 ranking on Google. Google says it directly, and warns against SEOs who claim to guarantee rankings or claim a special relationship with Google.
• An audit should give realistic estimates. Google describes a good SEO audit as one that estimates the likely improvement and the work involved. If someone guarantees their changes will put you in first place, Google’s advice is to find someone else.
• It takes time. Google tells owners to expect an SEO to need four months to a year to make improvements and see the benefit.

That is the company that runs the search engine telling you, in writing, that a ranking guarantee is not something anyone can honestly give.

Five shapes a guarantee takes

Guarantees rarely say “we control Google.” They come dressed up. Here are the common versions and the catch in each.

1. “Page one in 90 days”

The catch is usually the keyword. Page one for a phrase nobody searches is easy. Page one for the phrase that actually brings customers is not. Ask which exact phrases, in which city, on which device, and how many people search them each month.

2. “Top three or your money back”

A refund clause is not a ranking. It is a bet the seller has priced in. Read how the refund works: many apply only to part of the fee, only after many months, or only if you never cancelled early.

3. “Guaranteed 20 links a month”

This one guarantees an activity, which sounds safer. The problem is what the activity often is. Links that are bought or traded at a fixed monthly count are the pattern Google’s spam policies describe as link spam, and those links can be ignored or can count against a site.

4. “Guaranteed traffic”

Traffic is easy to inflate and hard to tie to sales. Visits from the wrong country, the wrong intent or no intent at all show up as a nice graph and never call you.

5. “Guaranteed leads”

Leads are closer to what you actually want, which is why this one is tempting. But the agency does not control your market, your prices, your reviews or how fast you answer the phone. A lead guarantee is either a refund clause, a definition of “lead” so loose it counts spam, or leads bought from somewhere else and shared with your competitors.

Why guarantees often lead to worse SEO

A guarantee changes what the agency is paid to do. Instead of growing your business, it is paid to hit the guaranteed number. That creates three bad habits.

Easy targets. The fastest way to hit a ranking promise is to pick phrases nobody competes for. You get a report full of green arrows and a phone that does not ring.

Shortcuts. When a deadline is in the contract, tactics that work fast and break later become attractive. Bought links and thin pages can move a number this quarter and cost you next year.

Hiding the real measure. The thing you care about, calls and booked jobs, rarely appears in a guarantee, because nobody can promise it.

What an honest SEO can promise

An honest SEO can still promise plenty. It just promises the things it controls.

• The work. What will be done, in plain English, and a way for you to see it was done.
• An estimate, labeled as an estimate. A realistic range of time, based on your site, your competition and your budget, with the reasons it could run longer.
• Reporting tied to money. Calls, form leads and booked jobs, not just rankings and traffic.
• Straight talk. Telling you when something is not working and what changes next.
• Clean methods. Nothing that puts your site at risk under Google’s spam policies.

That is the standard we hold ourselves to. It is why our SEO packages publish every price and a realistic timeline for each piece of work, and why none of them promises a ranking.

Ten questions to ask before you hire

1. What exactly will you do in the first 30 days?
2. Which phrases will you target, and how many people search them?
3. How long do you expect before I see calls, and why?
4. How will you measure calls and form leads, not just rankings?
5. How do you get links, and can I see examples?
6. Will I own my website, my Google Business Profile and my analytics?
7. What happens if I cancel? Do I keep the work?
8. Who actually does the work, and can I talk to them?
9. Can I speak to a client who has been with you for a year?
10. What would make you tell me SEO is not right for my business?

The last one is the best test. An SEO who can name a situation where you should not hire them is usually one you can trust.

If you have already been burned

You are not alone, and it is not your fault for believing a confident salesperson. Before you start again, do three things. Make sure you have owner access to your website, your Google Business Profile, Google Analytics and Search Console. Ask your old agency for a list of the links and pages they built, so you know what is out there. And read the signs that SEO is working, so next time you can tell for yourself in the first few months.

If you want a second opinion, our free SEO audit looks at where you stand today, and you can see how long your goal might take on the SEO Time Machine.

Keep going